Thursday, August 2, 2012

"So, what were your experiences with tear gas?"

I've spent the past three days at one of those workshops that universities not only organize but also pays faculty to attend. I will confess that the best thing about attending (besides the stipend) is getting to know other professors you may not interact with on a regular basis. Inevitably, I also always manage to get irritated with somebody and respond accordingly. This time was not the exception. 

One thing I hate is when Americans dismiss my political opinions and experience. They were a core component of my life experience growing up, so I don't take it lightly. I can also be pretty blunt about it, but I do not apologize for it nor is something I am willing to change. As an example, I pissed off quite a few people online and offline last Fall with my skepticism re the OWS movement and their lack of clear objectives. I don't think I've been proven wrong, but some people still prefer the nice-sounding buzz of certain words (horizontal democracy, no authority, assembly, etc) than a more pragmatic approach to problems. 

But I digress. This time, what managed to get me was a professor who barely knows me questioning the importance I assign to public education. It started with me making a comment about public schools that I do not even remember, but that could probably have been constructed as dismissive of public schools. This professor said out loud, with a clear tone of irony in her voice:

"Well, thanks SP, for your vote of confidence in public education. Do you even have any experience with it?" 

I politely replied:

"I'm sorry if I said something that was offensive. It was not my intention. I assure you that public education is something any progressive Argentinean is devoted to, and has fought for as some point in her/his life". 

To which she replied, "Yeah, of course" rolling her eyes. Besides the fact that I do not like being attack by somebody I barely know in a public setting (this was a group discussion with 10 other faculty members), the patronizing tone just got to me. I just looked at her and said calmly, with the best fake smile I could find:

"Yeah, really. The first time I was teargassed in my life was when I was 16, in Buenos Aires, in a protest against the government's attempt to privatize higher education in Argentina. We were successful, and that's the reason why until today, the best universities in my country are tuition-free."

(True story, in case you are wondering)

*Crickets* *Crickets*

Finally, a professor from a country from the former Soviet Union broke the silence saying: 

"Oh, me too! I got teargassed for the first time as a teenager in a demonstration against the Soviet Union in the 80s. It sucked, but those were exciting times".

I don't think I'll get challenged again in the near future. To my readers: Have you had any experience with tear gas?

5 comments:

  1. The only experience I -- or most other American civilians -- have with tear gas is reading about other people's experiences with it. Shame on your colleague for being such a condescending ass. You, on the other hand, are awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks! I do not dismiss anybody's opinion based on "street cred" (to put it someway), but I will flaunt mine if you challenge me. Or are an aggressive ass without any reason.

    ReplyDelete
  4. No absorption of tear gas outside California and Spain, but I make an effort to avoid it - .

    ReplyDelete
  5. My last time was December 19th, 2001, and I make the same effort. For example, I refused to allow students to go to a demonstration against Daniel Ortega when we were in Nicaragua.

    ReplyDelete